Forum

Please or Register to create posts and topics.

How to Work Together for Smart City Standards

bsdinsight@bsdinsight-com
837 Posts
#1 · 16 May 2025, 16:44
 
The document “How to Work Together for Smart City Standards” by SangKi Hong provides a detailed exploration of the role of geospatial standards, particularly those under ISO/TC 211 (Geographic Information/Geomatics), in fostering collaboration with other ISO technical committees like ISO/TC 268 (Sustainable Cities and Communities), ISO/IEC JTC 1/WG 11 (Smart Cities), and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41 (Internet of Things and Digital Twin). Below is a comprehensive response addressing the key points outlined in your query, focusing on ISO standards, collaboration, geospatial relevance, IoT/digital twin integration, service delivery phases, collaboration roadmap, cross-domain interoperability, use cases, integrated frameworks, and emerging technologies.
 
 

1. Focus on ISO Standards & Collaboration

The document emphasizes the need for collaboration among ISO technical committees to develop harmonized standards for smart cities. ISO/TC 211, which focuses on geographic information and geomatics, plays a pivotal role in providing geospatial standards that can integrate with other domains, such as sustainable urban development (ISO/TC 268), smart city ICT frameworks (ISO/IEC JTC 1/WG 11), and IoT/digital twin technologies (ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41). Collaboration is essential to avoid duplicative efforts and ensure interoperability across domains.
 
  • Key Standards from ISO/TC 211:
    • ISO 19115-1: Metadata fundamentals for geospatial data, critical for data sharing and interoperability.
    • ISO 19110: Methodology for feature cataloguing, enabling standardized descriptions of geographic features.
    • ISO 19107: Spatial schema for geospatial modeling.
    • ISO 19109: Rules for application schema, facilitating data structure consistency.
    • ISO/TS 19166: BIM to GIS conceptual mapping (B2GM), bridging building information modeling (BIM) with geospatial frameworks.
 
  • Collaboration with Other Committees:
    • ISO/TC 268: Focuses on sustainable cities, with standards like ISO 37156 (data exchange and sharing for smart community infrastructures) and ISO/DIS 37110 (open data management guidelines).
    • ISO/IEC JTC 1/WG 11: Develops ICT standards for smart cities, such as ISO/IEC 30145 series (smart city ICT reference frameworks) and ISO/IEC 5087 series (city data models).
    • ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41: Addresses IoT and digital twin standards, including ISO/IEC 30141 (IoT reference architecture) and ISO/IEC AWI 30173 (digital twin concepts and terminology).
 
The document advocates for joint efforts to align these standards, leveraging geospatial data as a common linkage to integrate physical and digital infrastructures in smart cities.
 
 

2. Geospatial Relevance

Geospatial standards are central to smart city infrastructure, enabling data exchange, urban planning, and decision-making. The document highlights how ISO/TC 211 standards, particularly those related to metadata and feature cataloguing, are relevant to smart city frameworks.
 
  • Metadata Standards (ISO 19115-1, ISO 19115-2, ISO/TS 19115-3):
    • These standards provide structured descriptions of geospatial data, ensuring discoverability and usability across smart city applications. For example, metadata supports data exchange in ISO 37156 (smart community infrastructure guidelines).
    • They enable decision-making by providing context for geospatial datasets, such as location, quality, and usage constraints.
 
  • Feature Cataloguing (ISO 19110):
    • This standard defines methodologies for cataloguing geographic features, ensuring consistent representation of entities like buildings, roads, or utilities. It is critical for integrating geospatial data with smart city infrastructures, such as in ISO/AWI TS 37172 (geo-information-based data exchange).
 
  • Applications in Smart Cities:
    • Geospatial standards support urban data integration frameworks (e.g., **ISO/DIS 37166**) for smart city planning.
    • They facilitate interoperability between BIM and GIS, as seen in **ISO/TS 19166**, which maps building data to geospatial contexts for smart building systems (**ISO/WD 37173**).
    • Geospatial data underpins decision-making in areas like transportation planning (**ISO/IEC 5087-3**) and public health emergency platforms (**ISO/IEC 5153**).
 
The document underscores that geospatial standards provide a foundation for linking physical (built and natural environments) and digital (ICT and IoT) worlds in smart cities.
 
 

3. IoT and Digital Twin Integration

The integration of IoT and digital twin technologies with geospatial frameworks is a key focus, as these technologies enable real-time data collection, modeling, and simulation for smart cities.
 
  • IoT Standards (ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41):
    • ISO/IEC 30141: Defines a reference architecture for IoT systems, providing a framework for integrating sensor data with geospatial information.
    • ISO/IEC 30161: Specifies requirements for IoT data exchange platforms, relevant for smart city services like smart grids (**ISO/IEC 30101**) and asset monitoring (**ISO/IEC 30163**).
    • ISO/IEC 29182 series: Outlines sensor network reference architectures, critical for collecting geospatial data from distributed sensors.
 
  • Digital Twin Standards:
    • ISO/IEC AWI 30173: Establishes concepts and terminology for digital twins, which are virtual representations of physical assets (e.g., buildings, infrastructure).
    • ISO/IEC AWI 30172: Documents use cases for digital twins, such as urban planning and infrastructure management, which rely on geospatial data for spatial accuracy.
 
  • Linkages to Geospatial Frameworks:
    • IoT sensor data can be georeferenced using ISO 19156 (observations and measurements) and ISO 19107 (spatial schema), ensuring spatial context for real-time data.
    • Digital twins can leverage ISO/TS 19166 (BIM-GIS mapping) to integrate building models with geospatial environments, enhancing urban simulations.
    • The document suggests harmonizing IoT and digital twin standards with geospatial reference models (**ISO 19101-1**) to create a unified framework for smart cities.
 
 

4. Service Delivery Phases

The document structures its analysis around service delivery phases, mapping standards to stages like Modelling, Data Build, Process, Collect, and Apply. This framework illustrates how geospatial and ICT standards contribute to each phase of smart city development.
 
  • Modelling:
    • Involves creating frameworks and reference models. Geospatial standards like ISO 19101-1 (reference model) and ISO 19107 (spatial schema) align with ICT standards like ISO/IEC 30145 series (smart city ICT frameworks) and ISO/IEC 30141 (IoT reference architecture).
    • Example: Applying ISO 19109 (application schema) to city data models (**ISO/IEC 5087 series**) for consistent data structures.
 
  • Data Build:
    • Focuses on creating pre-processed datasets. Standards like ISO 19115-1 (metadata) and ISO 19110 (feature cataloguing) support data integration for smart city platforms (**ISO/IEC 24039**).
    • Example: Using ISO/TS 19166 (B2GM) to map BIM data to geospatial datasets for smart building systems (**ISO/WD 37173**).
 
  • Process:
    • Involves data processing and service delivery. Geospatial APIs (**ISO 19168-1**) can integrate with IoT data exchange platforms (**ISO/IEC 30161**) to enable cloud-native and edge computing solutions.
    • Example: Harmonizing geospatial APIs with IoT APIs for real-time urban data processing.
 
  • Collect:
    • Focuses on data collection, particularly from sensors. ISO 19156 (observations and measurements) integrates IoT edge computing (**ISO/IEC TR 30164**) for trustworthy data collection.
    • Example: Georeferencing IoT sensor data for real-time urban monitoring.
 
  • Apply:
    • Involves applying data to specific use cases. Geospatial standards support applications like smart grids (**ISO/IEC 30101**), public health platforms (**ISO/IEC 5153**), and autonomous vehicles.
    • Example: Developing pilot systems for smart grids using geospatial data for spatial accuracy.
 
This phased approach ensures that standards are systematically applied across the smart city lifecycle, from data modeling to application deployment.
 
 

5. Collaboration Roadmap

The document outlines a phased roadmap for collaboration between ISO/TC 211 and other committees to develop harmonized smart city standards:
 
  1. Examine Current State and Write Technical Report (TR):
    1. Identify common interests across domains (e.g., geospatial, ICT, IoT).
    2. Document gaps and overlaps in existing standards to guide collaboration.
 
  1. Joint Workshop:
    1. Convene stakeholders from ISO/TC 211, ISO/TC 268, ISO/IEC JTC 1/WG 11, and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41 to develop shared use cases and service scenarios.
    2. Example: Workshops to align ISO 37156 (data exchange) with ISO 19115-1 (metadata).
 
  1. Joint Project:
    1. Initiate pilot projects and testbeds to validate interoperability between standards.
    2. Example: A pilot smart grid system integrating ISO/IEC 30101 with ISO 19156 for geospatial sensor data.
 
  1. Joint Working Group:
    1. Establish formal joint working groups (e.g., JWG GIS-BIM TC211-TC59/SC13) to develop joint standards.
    2. Example: Developing a unified standard for BIM-GIS interoperability based on **ISO/TS 19166**.
 
This roadmap emphasizes incremental collaboration, starting with knowledge sharing and culminating in standardized solutions.
 
 

6. Cross-Domain Interoperability

The document advocates for harmonizing geospatial standards with smart city domains to achieve cross-domain interoperability, particularly through BIM-GIS integration and IoT sensor networks.
 
  • BIM-GIS Integration:
    • ISO/TS 19166 (B2GM) provides a conceptual mapping between BIM and GIS, enabling seamless integration of building data with geospatial contexts.
    • Example: Applying B2GM to ISO/WD 37173 (smart building systems) to ensure buildings are spatially contextualized within urban environments.
    • This integration supports applications like smart city planning (**ISO/DIS 37166**) and infrastructure governance (**ISO/CD 37170**).
 
  • IoT Sensor Networks:
    • ISO/IEC 29182 series (sensor network reference architecture) and ISO/IEC 30161 (IoT data exchange) can integrate with geospatial standards like ISO 19156 (observations and measurements) to georeference sensor data.
    • Example: Using ISO 19109 (application schema) to standardize IoT sensor interfaces for applications like smart grids and asset monitoring.
 
  • Harmonized Frameworks:
    • The document proposes aligning geospatial reference models (**ISO 19101-1**) with smart city ICT frameworks (**ISO/IEC 30145 series**) and IoT architectures (**ISO/IEC 30141**) to create interoperable systems.
    • This ensures that data from diverse sources (e.g., 3D models, sensor data) can be integrated into a cohesive smart city infrastructure.
 
 

7. Use Cases and Applications

The document highlights practical applications where geospatial and ICT standards converge to address smart city challenges:
 
  • Smart Grids:
    • ISO/IEC 30101 defines sensor network interfaces for smart grid systems, which can leverage ISO 19156 for georeferenced sensor data to optimize energy distribution.
    • Use case: A pilot smart grid system integrating geospatial data for real-time load balancing.
 
  • Public Health Emergencies:
    • ISO/IEC 5153 outlines city service platforms for public health emergencies, which can use ISO 19115-1 metadata to manage geospatial health data.
    • Use case: Mapping disease outbreaks with real-time geospatial data for rapid response.
 
  • Autonomous Vehicles:
    • Geospatial standards (**ISO 19141**, schema for moving features) support connected autonomous vehicles by providing spatial data for navigation and traffic management.
    • Use case: Integrating ISO/IEC 5087-3 (transportation planning) with geospatial APIs for real-time routing.
 
  • Digital Twins for Smart Cities:
    • ISO/IEC AWI 30172 (digital twin use cases) relies on geospatial data for accurate urban simulations, supported by ISO/TS 19166 for BIM-GIS integration.
    • Use case: Simulating urban traffic flow using digital twins with geospatial context.
 
These use cases demonstrate the practical impact of standardized interoperability in addressing urban challenges.
 
 

8. Integrated Conceptual Framework

The document advocates for an integrated conceptual framework to bridge siloed standards (e.g., 3D data, sensor data, ICT standards) into a unified smart city infrastructure.
 
  • Current State (As-Is):
    • Standards are developed in silos, with geospatial, ICT, and IoT standards operating independently.
    • This leads to inefficiencies and interoperability challenges, as data formats and protocols vary across domains.
 
  • Proposed State (To-Be):
    • Geospatial standards (ISO/TC 211) serve as a common linkage, providing spatial context to integrate 3D data (BIM), sensor data (IoT), and ICT frameworks.
    • Example: A unified framework combining ISO 19115-1 (metadata), ISO/IEC 30145 (smart city ICT), and ISO/IEC 30141 (IoT architecture) to enable seamless data exchange.
 
  • Benefits:
    • Enhanced interoperability across smart city applications, from urban planning to real-time monitoring.
    • Reduced redundancy in standard development, as committees collaborate on shared frameworks.
    • Improved scalability, allowing cities to adopt standardized solutions tailored to their needs.
 
The document illustrates this transition with a diagram (Page 26), showing geospatial standards as the backbone of a harmonized smart city ecosystem.
 
 

9. Focus on Emerging Technologies

The document aligns geospatial and ICT standards with emerging technologies to address future smart city needs:
 
  • Edge Computing:
    • ISO/IEC TR 30164 (IoT edge computing) integrates with ISO 19156 to support real-time geospatial data collection at the edge.
    • Example: Real-time traffic monitoring using edge devices with georeferenced sensor data.
 
  • Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Deep Learning:
    • Geospatial data science leverages AI for big data processing, supported by standards like ISO 19115-1 for metadata management.
    • Example: Predictive urban analytics using AI with geospatial datasets.
 
  • Real-Time Data:
    • Standards like ISO/IEC AWI 30165 (real-time IoT framework) and ISO 19141 (schema for moving features) enable real-time geospatial applications.
    • Example: Real-time navigation for autonomous vehicles using geospatial APIs.
 
  • Digital Ethics and Privacy:
    • The document acknowledges the need for standards addressing ethical data use, particularly in applications like public health platforms (**ISO/IEC 5153**).
    • Example: Ensuring privacy in geospatial health data using metadata standards.
 
These technologies are critical for next-generation smart cities, and the document emphasizes their integration with geospatial frameworks.
 
 

10. Summary: Standardization, Interoperability, and Collaboration

The document underscores the importance of standardization, interoperability, geospatial data integration, and multi-committee collaboration to support smart city development. Key takeaways include:
 
  • Standardization: ISO/TC 211 standards (e.g., **ISO 19115-1**, **ISO 19110**) provide a foundation for geospatial data management, while ISO/TC 268, ISO/IEC JTC 1/WG 11, and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 41 address complementary smart city domains.
  • Interoperability: Harmonizing geospatial, ICT, and IoT standards ensures seamless data exchange and application integration, as seen in BIM-GIS mapping and IoT sensor networks.
  • Geospatial Data Integration: Geospatial standards link physical and digital worlds, enabling applications like smart grids, public health platforms, and digital twins.
  • Multi-Committee Collaboration: A phased roadmap (examination, workshops, pilot projects, joint working groups) fosters collaboration to develop unified standards.
 
By bridging siloed standards and leveraging emerging technologies, the proposed framework enhances the scalability, efficiency, and resilience of smart city infrastructures.
 
 
If you have specific questions or need further details on any section (e.g., specific standards, use cases, or collaboration strategies), please let me know!
Uploaded files:
  • You need to login to have access to uploads.
Click for thumbs down.0Click for thumbs up.0